Various methods have been used for identifying a particular plasticity, and different standards of consistency have been pro posed; * but none are without objection. The attempt is to adopt a consistency which shall be a compromise between that which will give the greatest strength and that which will give the most uniform results. Two methods of obtaining the same degree of plasticity will be described, viz.: 1, the one proposed by the Committee of the American Society for Testing Materials, which has been generally adopted in this country, and which for convenience will here be called the penetration method; and 2, a method somewhat like one frequently employed in France, and which will here be called the ball method.
The paste must be mixed as follows: "The material is weighed and placed on the mixing table and a crater formed in the center, into which the proper percentage of clean water is poured; the material on the outer edge is turned into the crater by the aid of a trowel. As soon as the water has been absorbed, which should not require more than one minute, the operation is completed by vigor ously kneading with the hands for an additional one and a half minutes, the process being similar to that used in kneading dough.
The paste should then be quickly formed into a ball with the hands, completing the operation by tossing it six times from one hand to the other, maintained 6 inches apart; the ball is then pressed into the hard-rubber ring, through the larger opening, and smoothed off. The ring is then placed on its large end on a glass plate, and the smaller end is smoothed off with a trowel. The paste, confined in the ring resting on the plate, is placed under the rod bearing the cylinder, which is brought into contact with the surface and quickly released."* The paste is of normal consistency, i.e., of proper plasticity, if the rod penetrates to a depth of 10 millimeters. If the penetration is not the correct amount, a new portion of cement should be weighed out and mixed with more or less water as the case may require, and a new trial made. For any particular cement the exact amount of water required to produce the standard degree of plasticity can be determined only by experiment; but portland cements require from 18 to 24 per cent, usually 19 to 21, and natural cements from 30 to 40 per cent, usually from 34 to 37 per cent.
The consistency recommended above is wetter than has fre quently been employed in the past; but is believed to give more uniform results than a dryer mixture. Some specifications, particu larly those of the U. S. Army Engineers, require that all cements be mixed with the same quantity of water; but this is not generally considered good practice, since the action of different cements is more nearly the same when mixed to a uniform consistency than when mixed with a uniform quantity of water.
With the usual portland cement only about 12 to 14 per cent of water is required for chemical combination, and consequently the water required to produce normal plasticity is considerably more than is required for the hydration..