It flows from his heart as joyful thanks for tokens of continued mindfulness of him recently received from his old Philippian friends through Epaphroditus, one of their number. Touched and filled with spiritual joy, he turns to comfort his friends in their sorrow for him, out of the stores of Divine consolation received through his own fresh sense of need (cf. 2 Cor. i. 3 sqq.). "Re joice in the Lord" is its recurring note. Here we get the word of the hour, both for Paul and for his converts.
Of the remaining epistles written during his imprisonment in Rome, the little note to Philemon touching his slave Onesimus casts fresh light on Paul "the Christian gentleman," by its humour and considerateness. The two larger ones do not
seem at first sight to reflect his personality so much as his life as the father of churches, and the way in which he extended the lines of his gospel, to bear on problems raised by ever fresh reactions upon it of the old traditions amid which his Asian converts still lived (see COLOSSIANS). Both aspects really blend; for the epistles are addressed to churches which were feeling certain effects of the seeming calamity that had overtaken him whom they in some sense regarded as their founder, and aim at raising them to the writer's own higher standpoint (Eph.
13, vi. 19-22; Col. ii. I seq., iv. 8 seq.).
But of this there is no real trace in the Pastorals, which are a type of letter by themselves as regards their recipients and cer tain of the aspects of church life with which they deal. As dealing with methods of instruction and organization, which must have increasingly occupied the attention of those responsible for the daily course of church life, they contain nothing inappropriate to the last two years of Paul's life, when he was considering how his churches might best be safeguarded from errors.
The main difficulties as to their substance have been imported by anachronistic reading of them, and are falling to the ground with the progress of exegesis and knowledge of the conditions of early church life. Our real difficulties in conceiving the Pas torals as what they purport to be, relate to their form, and "lie in the field of language and of ideas as embodied in language" (Hort., Jud. Christ. p. 131). But these, even as regards style and syntax, are reduced to narrow limits, when once due weight is given to the analogies furnished by the now admitted Imprison ment Epistles. As to the rhythmic fragment in I Tim. iii. 16, not only is it one in type with that in Eph. v. 14, but may even be part of the same hymn. Hence there seem no insuperable difficulties as to the authenticity of all three epistles—which most scholars recognize as at least partly from Paul's pen, though they disagree as to the exact limits of the genuine fragments—if only a natural historic setting can be found for them in Paul's life. But there is a general assumption that this cannot be found within the limits allowed by Acts. Accordingly some reject the situa tions implied in them on the whole as unhistorical, while others postulate a period in Paul's life of which Acts says nothing, if it does not exclude it (for these theories see PASTORAL EPISTLES). The only virtually contemporary external evidence, too, refers to Paul (and Peter) as having been joined in the place of reward by the Neronian martyrs, and therefore as already dead in (1 Clem. vi.). Further no tradition is clear enough to override the implication of Acts (xx. 25 and 38, cf . xxvi. 32) that Paul never visited Asia after his farewell at Miletus. Accordingly room for the epistles must be found, if at all, within the two years or so allowed by Acts. The following is an attempt to show how this may be done.